Brigham Young V’s Spencer W Kimball
The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day saints has for many years denied that the doctrine of Adam-God was ever taught amongst the saints, history however, originally contributes this teaching to the Prophet Joseph Smith, however, it was taught in a wider audience during Brigham Young’s reign as prophet of the mormon church.
Even though the most common accounts of this teaching being taught comes from the Journals of Discourses, noting that the church allowed to be published uncorrected for many years, today, the Journal of Discouse Volumes are considered unapproved publications by the church.
However, the Journal of Discourses was not the only source where it can be shown that Brigham Young taught the Adam-God Doctrine, the LDS Churches own publication the Millennial Star also, printed the doctrine for the saints this was in response to Elder Caffall and how the saints should address the Adam-God Doctrine:
“…Adam is our Father and Our God, …the prophet and Apostle Brigham Young has declared it … it is the word of the Lord“ – Volume 16, Issue 34, 26 August 1854, Page 534.
On the 18 June 1873 once again the Doctirne of Adam-God was printed in the Church News newspaper, this was taken from a discourse delivery by Brigham Young on the 8th June 1873, he said:
“How much unbelief exists in the minds of the Latter-day Saints in regard to one particular doctrine which I revealed to them, and which God revealed to me—namely that Adam is our father and God—.” – Deseret News Weekly, 18th June 1873.
You will notice that Brigham Young never said this was a theory, he even rebuked the saints for their disbelief in the doctrine. There is a multitude of other church sanctioned publications where it can be proven this teaching was taught as doctrine, and I would be happy to supply these for reference as requested.
Now lets move forward in history to 1976 where the Prophet of the LDS Church Spencer W Kimball makes an outlandish statement during a General Conference speech. Spencer W Kimball tried to play down the whole doctrine taught a hundred years earlier as the Lord revealed to Brigham Young:
“Another matter. We hope that you who teach in the various organizations, whether on the campuses or in our chapels, will always teach the orthodox truth. We warn you against the dissemination of doctrines which are not according to the scriptures and which are alleged to have been taught by some of the General Authorities of past generations. Such, for instance, is the Adam-God theory. We denounce that theory and hope that everyone will be cautioned against this and other kinds of false doctrine.” – Ensign, Our Own Liahona, November 1976.
There are some major issues with the above statement made by President Spencer W Kimball, firstly he tells the saints that the Adam-God doctrine was not in harmony with scripture, this is an outright lie, Brigham actually said this doctrine was not in any scripture, and that it was new light. The Adam-God doctrine is now called a ‘theory’, another lie. He further went on to denounce the theory, in the end he called it false doctrine, well this is true when you consider it from mainline Christianity teachings of God the father, but still a lie as it was considered true doctrine, when delivered by Brigham Young.
In summary, you have two Prophets of the same church in direct conflict over doctrinal teachings. Either one was right or one was wrong! This leads everyone to a very important question, as a Prophet did Brigham Young lead the saints astray, or was it Spencer W Kimball?
Either way, one of them was teaching false doctrine.